Skip to content

Question

Math 6010 • Linear Models

Spring 2008 • Question 9

Let \(X\) and \(Y\) be independent, each having the standard normal distribution, and let \((R,\Theta )\) be the polar coordinates for \((X,Y)\).

(a) Show that \(X+Y\) and \(X-Y\) are independent, and that \(R^2=[(X+Y)^2+(X-Y)^2]/2\), and conclude that the conditional distribution of \(R^2\) given \(X-Y\) is the chi-squared with one degree of freedom translated by \((X-Y)^2/2\).

(b) Show that the conditional distribution of \(R^2\) given \(\Theta \) is chi-squared with two degrees of freedom.

(c) If \(X-Y=0\), the conditional distribution of \(R^2\) is chi-squared with one degree of freedom. If \(\Theta =\pi /4\) or \(\Theta =5\pi /4\), the conditional distribution of \(R^2\) is chi-squared with two degrees of freedom. But the events \(\{X-Y=0\}\) and \(\{\Theta =\pi /4\}\cup \{\Theta =5\pi /4\}\) are the same. Resolve the apparent contradiction.

Raw LaTeX

Let \(X\) and \(Y\) be independent, each having the standard normal
distribution, and let \((R,\Theta)\) be the polar coordinates for \((X,Y)\).

(a) Show that \(X+Y\) and \(X-Y\) are independent, and that
\(R^2=[(X+Y)^2+(X-Y)^2]/2\), and conclude that the conditional distribution of
\(R^2\) given \(X-Y\) is the chi-squared with one degree of freedom translated by
\((X-Y)^2/2\).

(b) Show that the conditional distribution of \(R^2\) given \(\Theta\) is
chi-squared with two degrees of freedom.

(c) If \(X-Y=0\), the conditional distribution of \(R^2\) is chi-squared with one
degree of freedom. If \(\Theta=\pi/4\) or \(\Theta=5\pi/4\), the conditional
distribution of \(R^2\) is chi-squared with two degrees of freedom. But the
events \(\{X-Y=0\}\) and \(\{\Theta=\pi/4\}\cup\{\Theta=5\pi/4\}\) are the same.
Resolve the apparent contradiction.